| Part definition and drawing control | Confirm whether the quoted item is a copper commutator, carbon brush, or complete brush-and-commutator assembly. Dimensions and tolerances must match the approved pump design. | Controlled 2D drawing, material callouts, revision history, and a sample measured against the drawing. | 15% |
| Commutator construction | Segmented conductive bars are commonly made from copper or a copper alloy and insulated from one another. Segment count, bar geometry, and connection method are design-specific. | Material specification, construction description, segment-count confirmation, and inspection records for insulation and assembly. | 15% |
| Brush material and contact compatibility | Carbon or graphite brush grade must be selected for the motor’s current, speed, contact pressure, and operating environment. Brush and commutator materials must be assessed as a pair. | Brush-grade data, contact-system recommendation, wear-test results, and evidence that the proposed grade is suitable for the application. | 15% |
| Electrical performance | For a 12 V passenger-vehicle pump, the motor is designed around a 12 V nominal vehicle electrical system; actual voltage and current limits depend on the vehicle and pump specification. | Test results at the agreed operating conditions, including voltage, current, temperature, and any specified electrical-noise limits. | 15% |
| Dimensional consistency | Commutator outside diameter, length, shaft fit, runout, segment spacing, and terminal geometry are set by the motor design; there is no single universal size. | First-article inspection report with measured values, agreed tolerances, and a documented measurement method. | 10% |
| Durability and wear | Service life depends on load, speed, temperature, fuel-pump design, brush pressure, and material pairing. A meaningful life target must be agreed for the specific application. | Endurance-test protocol and results, test conditions, sample quantity, failure criteria, and wear measurements. | 10% |
| Fuel and environmental compatibility | Materials and assembly processes should be qualified for the intended in-tank or fuel-exposed environment, including the specified fuel blend and temperature range. | Compatibility statement tied to the application, material declarations, and relevant environmental test results. | 8% |
| Quality management and traceability | Production controls should identify the production lot and support investigation of nonconforming parts. Certification requirements should be verified for the actual manufacturing site and scope. | Current quality-system certificates, lot-traceability example, control plan, and nonconformance-correction process. | 7% |
| Sampling, lead time, and change control | Confirm sample approval, production lead time, minimum order quantity, packaging, and notification requirements for changes to materials, tooling, or process. | Written quotation, sample plan, production schedule, packaging specification, and documented change-notification procedure. | 5% |
| Total evaluation weight | Use the same application requirements and evidence checklist when comparing qualified suppliers. | Score each supplier against verified documents and sample-test results rather than price alone. | 100% |