| 1 | Process suitability | Whether the proposed process—such as water scrubbing, pressure swing adsorption, membrane separation, or chemical absorption—fits the feed gas and intended product use. | Process description, design basis, feed-gas assumptions, and explanation of technology selection. | 15% |
| 2 | Feed-gas characterization | Ability to design for the actual methane, carbon dioxide, hydrogen sulfide, water vapor, oxygen, and contaminant levels, including expected variation. | Required inlet-gas analysis, operating envelope, pretreatment requirements, and provisions for variable feed composition. | 12% |
| 3 | Product-gas specification | Whether the guaranteed outlet quality meets the applicable pipeline, vehicle-fuel, or other end-use requirements. Specifications differ by destination and application. | A written outlet-gas guarantee listing methane content and limits for relevant impurities, with test and acceptance methods. | 14% |
| 4 | Methane recovery and emissions | Methane recovery performance, methane slip, and the treatment or handling of off-gas. Results depend on process design and operating conditions. | Guaranteed performance basis, mass balance, off-gas management description, and a method for measuring methane loss. | 12% |
| 5 | Energy and utility consumption | Expected electricity, heat, water, and consumables use at stated capacity and feed conditions, including utility needs for pretreatment and compression. | Utility balance with clearly stated boundaries, operating assumptions, and estimated consumption at normal and turndown conditions. | 10% |
| 6 | Capacity, turndown, and availability | Fit to the required gas flow, ability to operate at reduced flow, and the maintenance plan for continuous or intermittent operation. | Guaranteed flow range, design operating hours, maintenance schedule, and availability assumptions or references. | 8% |
| 7 | Materials and equipment design | Suitability of materials, seals, piping, and instrumentation for wet, corrosive gas and the specified pressure, temperature, and site environment. | Equipment list, material specifications, pressure design information, corrosion-control approach, and relevant inspection documents. | 8% |
| 8 | Automation and safety | Monitoring and control of process variables, alarms, shutdown functions, gas detection, and safe handling of flammable or toxic gases. | Control narrative, instrument list, alarm and shutdown philosophy, and project-specific safety documentation. | 8% |
| 9 | Compliance and project documentation | Ability to meet the codes, pressure-equipment rules, electrical requirements, and permitting conditions applicable at the installation site. | A compliance matrix identifying applicable requirements, exclusions, certificates, drawings, and documentation deliverables. | 6% |
| 10 | Lifecycle support and commercial clarity | Availability of commissioning, training, spare parts, troubleshooting, warranty support, and transparent pricing for replacement media or consumables. | Scope-of-supply list, warranty terms, spare-parts list, service response arrangements, and lifecycle cost assumptions. | 7% |
| Total suggested evaluation weight | 100% |