| Applicable standards | Confirm the governing product and test standards, their editions, and any local adoption or project-specific requirements. | IEC projects commonly reference IEC 62271-1 for common specifications and IEC 62271-100 for AC circuit-breakers. IEEE-based projects may use applicable parts of the IEEE C37 series. Do not assume IEC and IEEE ratings or test bases are interchangeable. | Standards list in the specification; type-test reports identifying the standard and edition; written confirmation of deviations. |
| System voltage and insulation level | Match the breaker’s rated voltage and insulation withstand ratings to the highest system voltage, earthing arrangement, and site conditions. | Common IEC rated-voltage classes include 12 kV, 17.5 kV, 24 kV, and 36 kV. A system’s nominal voltage alone is not enough to select the breaker class. | Rated-voltage and insulation data sheet; power-frequency and lightning-impulse withstand ratings; project insulation-coordination review. |
| Continuous current | Check normal and emergency load current, ambient temperature, enclosure conditions, altitude, ventilation, and any required derating. | Common medium-voltage continuous-current options include 630 A, 1,250 A, 2,000 A, and 2,500 A; availability and allowable ratings depend on the design and installation. | Rated normal current; temperature-rise test data; published derating limits; confirmation for the specified switchgear assembly. |
| Short-circuit breaking capacity | Compare rated short-circuit breaking current with the maximum calculated fault current at the installation point, including future system changes. | Common medium-voltage ratings include 16 kA, 20 kA, 25 kA, 31.5 kA, and 40 kA. The required value must come from the system fault study, not from a typical-rating list. | Rated short-circuit breaking current; applicable asymmetry and test-duty data; coordination with the latest fault study. |
| Short-time withstand and duration | Ensure the breaker and associated switchgear can withstand the specified fault current for the protection-clearing time and backup-protection interval. | Short-time withstand durations of 1 s or 3 s are commonly specified, but the required duration depends on the protection and system design. | Rated short-time withstand current and duration; short-time withstand test evidence; switchgear assembly rating. |
| Making current and operating duty | Verify short-circuit making capability, required operating sequence, reclosing duty, and the intended application. | Making-current capability and operating sequence must be stated for the selected breaker and evaluated under the applicable standard. Capacitor-bank, reactor, motor, and generator applications may need additional checks. | Rated short-circuit making current; specified operating sequence; application-specific switching test evidence where required. |
| Vacuum interrupter and switching application | Confirm suitability for the load type, switching frequency, transient recovery voltage conditions, and any risk of restrike or switching overvoltage. | Vacuum interruption is widely used in medium-voltage systems. Application checks are still necessary for duties such as frequent motor switching, capacitor switching, and reactor switching. | Application limits; switching-duty data; recommendations for surge protection or mitigation where the study indicates a need. |
| Operating mechanism and control supply | Check mechanism type, control voltage, trip and close coil requirements, auxiliary contacts, interlocks, and compatibility with the protection and control system. | Control supplies are project-specific and may use AC or DC. Confirm the actual voltage, allowable operating range, and required trip-circuit supervision arrangements. | Control schematic; coil and motor data; auxiliary-contact schedule; interlock and trip-circuit details. |
| Installation and environmental conditions | Verify indoor or outdoor use, fixed or withdrawable arrangement, mounting interface, altitude, temperature, humidity, pollution, and seismic requirements. | Rated performance may require correction at elevated altitude or outside stated ambient conditions. The breaker must be compatible with the specific switchgear design and interlocking system. | Installation drawings; environmental limits and derating guidance; interface dimensions; seismic qualification if specified. |
| Type tests and routine tests | Check that test evidence applies to the offered design and rating, and distinguish type-test evidence from routine production tests. | Relevant evidence can include dielectric, temperature-rise, short-circuit, mechanical-operation, and other tests required by the applicable standard and project specification. | Traceable type-test reports; routine test certificates for delivered units; serial-number and configuration matching. |
| Mechanical and electrical endurance | Assess expected operating frequency, switching duty, maintenance intervals, and the stated endurance classification or limits. | Endurance requirements depend on the standard, breaker design, and application. Compare declared performance with the expected number and type of operations. | Mechanical and electrical endurance declarations; maintenance instructions; operation counter and condition-check requirements. |
| Lifecycle support and spare parts | Confirm availability of trained service, technical documentation, compatible replacement parts, and support for the intended service life. | Include planned inspection, mechanism servicing, interrupter assessment, spare-part lead times, and obsolescence arrangements in the lifecycle review. | Service scope and response arrangements; spare-parts list; maintenance schedule; documentation and end-of-support commitments. |
| Final technical comparison | Compare offers on equal ratings, standards, test evidence, accessories, installation interfaces, and lifecycle scope—not only purchase price. | Record each requirement as compliant, non-compliant, or requiring clarification. Resolve exceptions before technical approval and procurement. | Completed compliance schedule; deviation register; approved drawings and data sheets; documented clarification responses. |