| Product range and application coverage |
15% |
Range of flow-control valve types, sizes, pressure classes, end connections, and applications offered. |
Current product catalogues, technical data sheets, and documented product configurations. |
| Technical compliance and certifications |
15% |
Compliance with standards relevant to the valve type and intended market; examples may include applicable GB/T, API, or ASME requirements. |
Valid certificates, product markings, test documentation, and confirmation of the exact scope and edition. |
| Quality management and inspection |
12% |
Documented quality controls covering incoming materials, machining, assembly, testing, and traceability. |
Quality-system certificates, inspection and test plans, calibration records, and sample inspection reports. |
| Product testing and performance validation |
12% |
Availability and suitability of pressure, shell, seat-leakage, and other required tests for the product and service conditions. |
Test procedures and reports identifying the product, test conditions, acceptance criteria, and results. |
| Materials and service suitability |
10% |
Material options and documented suitability for the specified pressure, temperature, fluid, and corrosion conditions. |
Material specifications, bills of materials, material test certificates, and application limits. |
| Manufacturing capability and capacity |
10% |
Relevant production processes, equipment, facility capability, and ability to meet stated order requirements. |
Factory audit findings, equipment lists, production records, and capacity information supported by documentation. |
| Customization and engineering support |
8% |
Ability to review specifications and provide documented options for materials, actuation, connections, and operating conditions. |
Engineering procedures, drawings, technical-submittal examples, and change-control records. |
| Delivery and order execution |
7% |
Documented lead-time commitments, order tracking, production planning, and delivery performance for comparable orders. |
Recent order records, agreed delivery schedules, and on-time delivery data with a stated measurement period. |
| Export and documentation readiness |
6% |
Experience preparing the export, packing, inspection, and product documents required for the destination and contract. |
Redacted export documentation samples, packing procedures, and destination-specific compliance records. |
| After-sales service and spare-parts support |
5% |
Availability of operating instructions, troubleshooting support, warranty terms, and compatible replacement parts. |
Service policies, manuals, spare-parts lists, and documented response and warranty procedures. |
| Total weighting |
100% |
Apply the same evidence-based scoring method to each manufacturer being compared. |